JohnN

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: rubber navy buttons #392

    JohnN
    Member

    In examining  7 frocks and 2 pairs of  trousers (not exactly an exhaustive survey), none of them used the button Blockade Runner sells.  Every button on them were bone or stamped tin (one had porcelain).  I have seen plenty of period pics of the Jacket and they don’t seem to feature that button either.  How large is Blockade Runner button?  Could it be the Pea Coat button?

    John

    in reply to: Bluejackets book #391

    JohnN
    Member

    I have a copy of the book and would make the following observations:

    It draws together many images that are spread over the net and brings them together into one print publication.  A large proportion of the images are readily found on the net if you have decent search skills and spend some time.  There are some images from non published collections to further illustrate the common ones.  The book is a convenient single place to refer to.

    The author does not delve deeply into the historical back ground of the clothing nor does he show construction, examination of materials, evidence of type of use, etc.  As I *think* many of these images were gathered from web sources and dealer’s web sites those sorts of details aren’t usually posted.  Entire books have been written about specific items like Federal sack coats or buckles or buttons.  That this single book should not be as detailed is to be expected. For some one who has never seen any original items, this book would be a useful survey.

    Hopefully, as interest in this forum grows, people will post pictures of what they have collected and we can examine, discuss and share what we find.

    John

Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)